Woodshop Bench All tools
Measuring & estimating

Wood species selector

Walnut for a cutting board is wrong. Poplar for a visible tabletop is fine but looks cheap. Maple for outdoor furniture is wrong. This selector weights hardness, stability, cost, workability and availability against your project type and gives you the top three species worth shortlisting.

Selector

How the scoring works

Each species has a row of attributes: Janka hardness (higher is harder, more dent-resistant), tangential shrinkage (lower is more dimensionally stable), average US retail board-foot price (lower is cheaper), and a workability rating (1 = tear-out-prone, 5 = carves like butter). The calculator normalises each attribute to a 0–100 scale and weights them by your priorities.

Where the calculator won't help is colour, grain figure and local availability — those are aesthetic and logistical decisions only you can make. Use this to filter, then go look.

Limitations

Frequently asked questions

Why is poplar recommended for drawer boxes but not a tabletop?

Poplar is dimensionally stable, machines cleanly and takes paint well — all you want for a hidden drawer box. As a visible tabletop it looks cheap (pale, greenish-grey, bland grain). The selector weights the "looks visible" property for tabletops and recommends species with stronger figure.

Is walnut worth the premium?

If you're building one piece you'll look at every day for ten years, yes. Walnut is stable, easy to work and ages beautifully. If you're building a project where most of the wood will be hidden or painted, no — poplar or maple will perform identically for a third of the price.

What about plywood and MDF?

Not on this selector. Plywood and MDF are engineered panels, not species — they're the right answer for cabinet backs, painted panels and shop jigs, but they're not what most people mean by "wood species". For sheet goods, the rule of thumb is: plywood for structural panels you can see the edge of; MDF for things you'll paint or that need a perfectly smooth surface.

Why no bamboo or other "eco" choices?

Bamboo is a grass, not a wood, and behaves very differently (it splits along the grain aggressively and won't hold a screw near an edge). There are legitimate reasons to use it but they need a different calculator. The same goes for reclaimed barn wood — its variability is the point, and our calculator assumes predictable new lumber.

How do I use Wood species selector step by step without mistakes?Follow the order given in the usage section: Pick a wood species by project type, budget, hardness and stability. Compares 14 common domestic and imported woods on a single weighted score. The step-by-step part matters less than the unit check that sits inside it. Confirm every unit matches the thing you are actually trying to measure before you press calculate - that single check catches more wrong answers than any other habit, and it costs about ten seconds.
What are the common mistakes when using Wood species selector?Most common mistakes come down to four habits: entering 20 when the field expects 0.2 because the field is a percentage; leaving a field blank and accepting the default without checking what it stands for; changing one input and reading a result that was calculated before the change; and quoting the output as an exact figure when the page describes it as a reference estimate. Press calculate again after any edit, and treat the number as a reference point rather than a final answer.